Additional Israeli Details on the Prisoner Exchange Deal: These “Gaps” Remain

The Hebrew newspaper Yedioth Ahronoth revealed today, Sunday, new Israeli details regarding the prisoner exchange deal with Hamas. It noted that discussions in Tel Aviv indicate progress in negotiations, with ongoing talks in Qatar.

The report highlighted that “both sides are interested in a deal. However, significant gaps still exist in reaching a prisoner exchange agreement, particularly regarding certain issues.” It also mentioned that “Hamas has sent a list of individuals it demands to be released. Discussions are ongoing, including vetoes on releasing some individuals and proposals to transfer others to different countries. Despite reports last week, Hamas has yet to present a list of the living prisoners it holds.”

The Major Gap

The article added, “One of the key issues is the matter of ending the war. In an interview published last Friday in The Wall Street Journal, Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu stated that he would not agree to a prisoner exchange deal that concludes the war with Hamas.” These statements sparked criticism from the families of Israeli captives.

The newspaper pointed out concerns among those involved in the negotiations that Netanyahu’s remarks could derail talks, even if they were previously made.

It also noted that the first phase of the deal would involve releasing 250 Palestinian prisoners. “Israel has submitted a list of 34 prisoners it demands to be freed in the initial stage of the exchange, including 11 prisoners who do not meet the criteria for this stage. Hamas has agreed to release those requested by Israel during the first phase, provided they receive special compensation.”

Accepting a Limited Deal

The report clarified that “the first phase of the prisoner exchange plan will not, under any circumstances, include a complete withdrawal of Israeli forces. However, Hamas insists on guarantees to halt the war. If the exchange progresses to the second phase—according to the original plan from last May, marking the end of the war—male and youth prisoners, as well as soldiers, will be released. The third phase, based on the original plan, would see the release of remains.”

According to Yedioth Ahronoth, Israel’s insistence on dismantling Hamas’ rule in Gaza, as emphasized by Netanyahu in his interview last night, casts doubt on Hamas’ willingness to accept a limited deal. This is particularly concerning given Israel’s likelihood of resuming military operations after the humanitarian phase.